20th Century Evening Sale
With fees; $521M at hammer, against an estimate of $511–743M. Kandinsky's Betonte Ecken set an artist record at $85.8M and Klimt's Litzlbergkeller made $82.3M. Of 75 lots offered, 66 sold; 31 carried third-party guarantees.
Notes from Jayme Rosenthal & Co. on the November marquee sales at Christie's and Sotheby's. Hammer prices exclude the buyer's premium, which is how estimates are quoted; totals and headline prices include it. The houses' final results govern where figures differ.
With fees; $521M at hammer, against an estimate of $511–743M. Kandinsky's Betonte Ecken set an artist record at $85.8M and Klimt's Litzlbergkeller made $82.3M. Of 75 lots offered, 66 sold; 31 carried third-party guarantees.
With fees ($117.7M at hammer, against an estimate revised to $126–192M); 51 of 56 lots sold. Richter's 1990 Abstraktes Bild drew no bids, and works by Koons and Ruscha were withdrawn. The Sonnabend and Agnes Gund collections anchored the evening, with the Basquiat Leonardo as the lead lot.
With fees, for twelve works ($358M at hammer, against an estimate of about $450M; six of the twelve hammered below their low estimates). Van Gogh's Châtaigniers en fleurs made $190.4M ($165M hammer, against about $180M expected), a record for the artist (previous: $117.2M), and Cézanne's Arlequin $111M ($99M hammer, against $120M). Those two lots were about 73% of the total.
With fees ($305.2M at hammer, inside an overall estimate of $260.2–378.4M). Magritte's L'Ami de l'ordre made $45.5M and Hopper's The Martha McKeen of Wellfleet $47.8M. Aaron Douglas's Harriet Tubman set a record at $14.5M against a $2.5–3.5M estimate. At hammer, 11 lots finished above their high estimates, 21 within range and 14 below their low estimates.
With fees ($85.75M at hammer), up 55% on last year. Modigliani's Tête made $44.6M against a $28–35M estimate and Hockney's David, Celia, Stephen and Ian $12.2M. 21 of 22 lots sold; 14 carried third-party guarantees.
With fees ($224.8M at hammer, just under the $226.2M low estimate), plus $109.9M from the Baum collection. Records for Kusama ($15M, 1960 work) and Sam Francis ($17.1M). Within it, the Hedreen Collection was led by Lichtenstein's Reflections on “Painter and Model” at $24.6M ($22M hammer, against $20–30M); de Kooning's Water… Soft Banks and a Window hammered at $17.1M, below its $20M low.
| Work | Estimate | Result | Reading |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basquiat, Untitled (Leonardo and His Five Grotesque Heads), 1983 | $30–50M | $28.0M hammer ($32.9M with fees) | Below the low estimate |
| Lichtenstein, The Large Spool, 1963 | $10–15M | $7.0M hammer | Well below the low estimate |
| Warhol, Campbell's Soup Can (Turkey Noodle), 1962 | $6–8M | $7.3M hammer | Within the range |
| Kandinsky, Betonte Ecken, 1922–23 | $60–80M | $74M hammer | Within the range; $85.8M with fees, an artist record |
| Giacometti, Figure, demie grandeur (no. 2), 1949 | $20–30M | $22M hammer | Within the range; offered without reserve |
| Picasso, Le Baiser, 1969 | $40–60M | $26.5M hammer | Well below the low estimate |
| de Kooning, Yellow River, 1958 | $12–18M | $11.0M with fees | Below the low estimate even with fees |
| Monet, Champ d'avoine et coquelicots | $12–18M | $26.0M with fees | Above the high estimate |
| Rodin, Le Penseur (moyen modèle) | $2.5–3.5M | $7.9M with fees | Far above the high estimate |
| Tanguy, Qui répondra? | $2–3M | $5.7M with fees | Far above the high estimate |
| Noguchi, Floating Lunar | $0.4–0.6M | $1.5M with fees | Far above the high estimate |
| Hopper, The Martha McKeen of Wellfleet, 1944 | $20–30M | $41M hammer | Well above the high estimate |
| Magritte, L'Ami de l'ordre, 1964 | $25–35M | $39M hammer | Above the high estimate |
| Aaron Douglas, Harriet Tubman, 1931 | $2.5–3.5M | $12M hammer | Auction record; proceeds benefit Bennett College |
| Modigliani, Tête, 1911–12 (Phillips) | $28–35M | $38.2M hammer | Above the high estimate |
| Celmins, Untitled (Ocean), 1990 | $6–8M | $5.75M hammer | Below the low estimate |
Christie's 21st Century hammers match the published results. Other hammers per The Art Newspaper. “With fees” is the price including the buyer's premium, where the hammer is not yet confirmed; even without fees those lots finish on the same side of their estimates. Estimates are from Christie's catalogue and exclude the premium.
Fresh, well-documented works with a clear story found buyers, and several artist records were set. Small, modestly estimated lots (Rodin, Tanguy, Noguchi) ran far past their ranges, while the weight of the week sat in a few trophy lots.
Several of the largest lots hammered at or below their low estimates. A guarantee can secure a result, but it cannot lift the price the room will pay.
A price with fees can look like a beat when the hammer sat inside the range. Comparing like with like is the first step in judging any result.
By Sotheby's own count, named single-owner collections made $1 billion of its $1.31 billion week: 78% of the value from 39% of the lots. A coherent collection with a documented story drew the money.
The Baums paid $65,000 for Joan Mitchell's Green Book of Barbara Guest in 1986 and $395,000 for Ruscha's Dimple in 2002. They sold this week for $19.3M and $11.6M. Before fees, insurance and inflation, that is what patient, early buying looks like.
Reserves and asking prices should follow the price at which comparable works actually cleared, not the estimate and not a past peak. A private sale can suit works that need a more patient audience.
Or a comprehensive diagnostic of up to five works · $7,500. Market advisory, not a formal appraisal.